One of the novels I’m working on, Blood and Loam, is set in 1970, and my main character, Stella, has come home in a daze from Kent State, trying to escape the violence. Of course, she will face her own war when she returns to her hometown, so there’s no running away from turmoil.
I was a kid when students marched and occupied school administration buildings to protest the Vietnam War. My only official protest occurred in high school a few years later when our teachers threatened to strike. A lot of us kids, in sympathy for our teachers, showed up at a school board meeting and disrupted it with our questions. We were angry, but nonviolent and asking sincere questions. The superintendent closed the board meeting to the public and called the state police, and we were ushered out. Some of us vowed to meet at the park on Saturday to discuss next steps, but I chickened out. I didn’t want to rock the boat.
In Zucotti Park, a group of people, many (though not all) of them young, have taken a strong stand — and I’m not just talking about the fact that many haven’t showered in days. They are willing to demonstrate for their future, to draw attention to corporate greed and government corruption. While hubby and I have talked privately about these matters, and occasionally slipped some money toward a political campaign, we did not take the added step of publicly declaring our concerns and organizing others who felt the same way.
As I visited with some of the young people, I saw that they are intelligent, thoughtful, and caring. We arrived early in the day, and some of the protesters were still sleeping, lined up in rows in the park. Others were walking around, chatting and making signs. A little while later, a row of drummers started playing.
There was an unexpected order to the park. One section was a designated library. In others, we saw a press room, complete with power; a kitchen area with a sign requesting vegetables and vegan food; an area where people could get socks and gloves for keeping warm during the night; and a medical area. It looked like a microcosm of a town.
The group acknowledges that they attract a wide range of people. Though the majority are young, and hence far more willing to spend days or weeks living outside, not all are. They even have their own newspaper, and one of the protesters gave me a copy of one. I read nothing “crazy” or even unrealistic in the paper, just newsy articles about the events going on.
Some thanked us for our support and asked us to go back to our homes to share the reality of what we saw. I thanked THEM for having the courage to take a stand. Americans are angry about corporate greed an corruption within our government. We have discussed these same issues privately in our own homes, but it never occurred to us that we could do something about it. Yes, we grew passive as we grew older, bemoaning the status quo but not having the courage to take a public stand.
Yes, these protesters have long hair, piercings, and tattoos, but they are exposing concerns that many of us have. It’s easy to “shoot the messenger,” but the message they are conveying is a valid one. I am reminded that back in the late 60s and early 70s, students were mocked for their appearance, but their protests made the war so unpopular that it did, I believe, make a difference. We can look back now and know that the hippies were right.
We were present to hear the “mic check” communications that go on — where one person yells “Mic check!” to get attention, and his or her words are shouted down the line to the group. During our stay there, they were looking for legal aid representatives. One of the women was being arrested for writing “Good morning, NYPD” on the sidewalk with chalk. Seriously?
That was the most disturbing part. The protesters were quietly talking and going about their business, not causing trouble. The police, on the other hand, seemed wired up and ready to confront. In fact, during one hubbub when we worked our way toward the action to see what was going on, Henry and I were briefly separated from each other. Worried that I was getting swept up into a mass arrest, I pulled back and turned around to look for him. A police officer brushed against me not once, but twice — and not because we were getting sandwiched together. I felt as though he was trying to either intimidate or provoke me. I pulled back to another area, getting as far away from him as I could, so I could call Henry. Fortunately, he found me at that moment, and we moved away from the action.
The protesters responded by inviting others to write on the sidewalk with chalk, a deliberate act of civil disobedience in solidarity with the woman who was arrested. We decided not to try our luck.
A few other observations:
- I did not see the sanitation issues being reported in the media. I did see people cleaning up after themselves and loading up garbage bags.
- I did not see chaos, but rather an organized and thoughtful demonstration.
- I did not see evidence of the conspiracy theorists’ opinions that George Soros is funding the movement. If he is, he isn’t doing a very good job. People were relying on donated food and passed a bucket to get other needed supplies. The bucket I saw had a handful of $1 bills in it.
“Spread the word,” one of them told me. “Go back to your city and tell everyone you know what you saw here.” I am doing that because I know that we are getting untruthful reporting in the mainstream media. It’s one thing to know that intellectually. It’s quite another to see it for myself, and I am sickened and disheartened at how sanitized the news has become. What else is going on that we haven’t learned about?
I am a fortunate woman. I live in an affluent area of Houston and visited Occupy Wall Street after leaving the safety and comfort of a hotel room. In a few days I will go back to a life that is largely insulated from many of the problems our country faces. I no longer have to work at a job where annual pressure was brought to bear on employees to financially support the company’s PAC — and, of course, its Republican candidates.
Still, we cannot sit idly by while our fellow Americans keep losing jobs, while our government gets increasingly bought and sold by corporate interests, and while those who brought the economy down receive special favors and corporate welfare. I am passing along what I have seen in hopes that these young people will, with enough voices raised in chorus, get the respect they are due for forcing attention to the many problems we as Americans all share.
Will marching on Wall Street solve our problems? Of course not. But if the attention called to our problems helps us shake off our apathy and vote, or to help grass roots service organizations keep going in a tough economy, or to defend our food supply by buying local and organic foods — in these ways and more, we are reminded by Occupy Wall Street that we can make a difference. We can make our country great again. We just have to fight a little harder.
Thanks for the report, Nadine. You’re so right about the comparison with the anti-war protesters from the 60s and 70s. We raise our children to value education, then we turn around and tell them that they don’t know what they’re talking about.
Another good post on what’s going on there. I was a part of the anti-Vietnam War protests. What good did it do? I have a very pessimistic view of these things.
Richard, first, thank you for serving your country in the way that you did…you fought, and some died, to draw attention to the absurdity of the Vietnam War. I value your contribution as much as I value that of soldiers, for you did what you did for the love of your country. What you and others did influenced people like me. I was too young to participate, but my politics and beliefs were shaped by what you did. Again, thank you. I believe that those protests did influence the government’s decision to end the war, even though they seemed on… Read more »
Thanks for spreading the real story. I am hungry for the truth. Love, Jodi
Thank you for passing the link to my blog on Twitter! I think it’s essential that we combat the myths and half-truths being reported.
Hi Nadine, I am from SheWrites and I saw the discussion on there with another member that made me very disturbed. It was the right wing blather about the demonstrators having no purpose, blah, blah, blah. Isn’t it enough that we, the middle class have been squeezed for years from the banks and the government. Isn’t it enough that our children, mostly the people demonstrating there have had to accept a lower life style because they can’t find decent jobs that pay them decent wages? People have lost their homes and our society’s infrastructure is crumbling due to the inability… Read more »
Hi, Barbara! Thank you for this heartfelt response. I saw the post and plan to respond to it tomorrow on the blog. We are going to have a bit of a history lesson! In the meantime, we are back at the protests, and I hope to have much more to share.
Nadine this was an excellent post. It was good to hear the truth rather than the media junk that comes through if you don’t listen to MSNBC or some other station.
I completely agree with Barbara Ehrentreu, it is time that the right wing blather go by the wayside and other voices are raised and heard. Thank you for making your voice heard!
Hugs!!!
Hugs back, Cat. It was hard for me to “come out” in this way. I knew I was risking the audience I am trying to build. But I had to report what I saw as I saw it, and the support thus far has been gratifying and overwhelming.
First Nadine I want to say that after reading your article more than once I am impressed by your “reporting” I think your article was wonderful and I am going to spread it as far as I can, second I THOUGHT I said SOMETHING about being careful??? Did I read that at one point you went TOWARD the protest and police part??? uh huh. But you know what, I KNEW you were going to do that because you reminded me of my niece when I would tell her to be careful and there was NO COMMENT that she had plans.… Read more »
Well, yeah, you got me there! But tonight when I saw the large contingent of police, I had a bad feeling, so we left before any of the speakers. I had hoped to share that experience but was unwilling to put myself in harm’s way to do so.
I agree that the left/right debates are obsolete. We have to get beyond that in order to solve the problems we have.
Hi, Nadine…. I’m another member of SheWrites who read, yet didn’t participate in the discussion there re: your post. I found your account of and comments regarding your visit to OWS to be thoughtful, measured, objective and sincere, and I appreciate the spirit of your post. I was a college student during the Vietnam era and remember full well the protests and the protesters, some of whom were my friends. My politics, at the time, were vastly different than they are now, so I never was a participant; however, I supported 100% their rights to peaceful assembly and freedom of… Read more »
Candice, this is a powerful share that touched my heart. Thank you for being so honest — your story is one shared by too many Americans. I truly believe that the majority of those in trouble right now have worked hard and tried to do the right things. My heart goes out to you for these struggles that you describe. May we see a better day, and soon!
Many things need addressed. Lobbyists need banned, the electoral college needs dissolved, price-gouging of necessities and moral decisions enforced through excessive taxation needs to stop. The welfare and disability systems need a total rewrite, credit agencies need to be reigned in, jobs cannot be shipped globally without a foundation remaining, and corporate greed needs to be capped. Litigation is out of control and there are so many laws it’s difficult to wipe one’s backside without knowing if a law is being broken. Now, that said, it is easy to proclaim what is wrong, but harder to offer solutions. The movement… Read more »
Thanks, Nadine. I hope that this post is read far and wide, and that folks start to understand what is at stake. In the late 70s and early 80s, I was a low level lobbyist, monitoring events on Capitol Hill on environmental issues. Some of the most progressive House and Senate members were Republicans — they and a bunch of Democrats, worked together to draft the Clean Air Act, the Clean Water Act and a whole host of others. This is, of course, a fact that I’m sure would send the Tea Party into Boston Harbor in an effort to… Read more »
Thanks for visiting and commenting! We have often looked back at those days and wonder what happened. It’s great to hear the viewpoint of someone who was there during a very different time.